You're Reading...
Site News

Can Washington teachers spell I-L-L-E-G-A-L? – Port Orchard Independent

Can Washington teachers spell I-L-L-E-G-A-L? – Port Orchard Independent.

Teachers from Bellevue, Northshore, and Snoqualmie Valley school districts have threatened to go on strike if they do not have a tentative contract agreement by August 31.

Not surprisingly, their concerns are focused on compensation.

“We are quite far apart on some main issues, mostly compensation and issues around the curriculum,” said Michele Miller of the Bellevue Education Association.

Public employees are presumed to provide essential services necessary for the health and safety of the state’s citizens.

Under the state constitution, Article IX, Section 1, the state has expressly stated that it is the paramount duty of the state to provide a public education.

Those charged with that duty are violating the law when they refuse to perform their duties.

The Washington Education Association and its local affiliates consistently have used strikes, and the threat of strikes, to intimidate school boards during contract negotiations.

Typically, union negotiators keep this tactic as a “last resort,” to get their way, but have always denied that their actions are illegal.

Since 1972, of the 29 cases in which court injunctions were sought to end teacher strikes in Washington, 24 were granted.

The teachers’ unions have never appealed any of the injunctions, likely out of fear that appellate courts would uphold the decisions of the trial courts, setting a more expansive precedent.

While the Legislature explicitly has made strikes illegal for all other public employees, they have been silent on teacher strikes thus far.

However, the state courts have been quite clear.

In 2002, Superior Court Judge Joan Dubuque issued an injunction against the Issaquah Education Association.

The court cited two prior Supreme Court decisions that did not involve injunctions which punted the issue to the Legislature, but the Legislature has remained silent.

Judge Dubuque then relied on other Washington courts’ decisions related to injunctions to end teacher strikes and held that teachers do not have the right to strike, “and what is going on is an illegal strike at this time.”

This finding was justified because, in the absence of statutory authority granting or denying the right for teachers to strike, teachers will be treated as public employees.

The result of the 49-day standoff in Marysville in 2003 was particularly costly.

The delay itself interfered with the college application process and delayed high school graduation for many seniors.

Parents were forced to pay for additional daycare or leave their children at home unsupervised.

Superior Court Judge Linda Krese granted an injunction to end the Marysville teacher strike.

The court held that the Marysville Education Association violated the prohibition on public employee strikes and was acting illegally.

Most recently, on Jan. 31, 2006, Attorney General Rob McKenna issued an opinion clarifying the illegality of teacher strikes in Washington state: “In Washington, public sector workers at the state and local level do not have a legally protected right to strike. No right has been granted by statute or common (judge-made) law.”

That seems pretty clear.

Aside from the illegality of teacher strikes, the equally hideous reality is that teacher union officials use the threat of a strike to bully school districts into giving them exactly what they want, whether the district can afford the demands or not.

Why would they threaten to do something illegal? Because there have never been any real sanctions imposed on the teacher unions who brought about the strikes.

In both cases above, the fines would have begun to stack up after the order was issued if the order was ignored, but teachers returned to work before that happened.

Union negotiators should not be permitted to hold children hostage and force district concessions with threats of illegal activity.

That’s a fine lesson to teach students: If you don’t get your way, threaten to do something illegal.

Sonya Jones is Director of the

Labor Policy Center at the

Evergreen Freedom Foundation.

About Brandia

I am an animals rescuer, a mother, a grandmother, a minister, & a human being who is tired of all the corruption going on in our state.


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Please Consider a Donation

We couldn't do this without you!
wordpress visitors
Washington State Bar Watch

Keeping Watch On Washington Lawyers

Snohomish County Sheriff's Watch

Keeping An Eye On Those In Power

Research Advocates NW

Finding Answers To Life's Mysteries

Trump Tracker

Keeping Track of the 45th's Alternative Facts

Missing and Murdered of Snohomish County

Because all life matters and none should be forgotten

Washington Activist

Private Information Sharing for Washington Activists

Real Estate Scams

Broken Dreams... Broken Lives

Clark County Conservative

Stateside Associates Listed 2012 “Best Local Politics Blog”

WA Social Justice Initiative

A grassroots community to help attain "Justice" for those unable to go it alone.


Res ipsa loquitur - The thing itself speaks

John Wills Lloyd

These are some personal views about living, loving, hoping, and such.

Fighting Corruption In Stevens County

The struggle for freedom lives here

Rose Marie Adams

The Evil That Lurks Within

Corrupt Washington

Fighting For Change

Did You Check First?

It's fine to have an opinion. It's better to know the facts.

Real Mommies and Daddies of the Real America and our Children who Want to Come Home


The Lizard Farmer

"You can't starve us out and you can't make us run 'cause we're them old boys raised on shotguns" -Bocephus


Call for compliance with 2010 UN Human Rights Sexual Assault Response

Protecting Peoples Rights

The sworn duty of all public servants

Rcooley123's Blog

Rick Cooley's Blog


Social Justice

No Loss for Words

Thoughts from a Back Bencher!


The website where movies count

We Hold These Truths To Be Self-Evident

that all men are created equal

Simply Sumptious

at the Corrigan Cafe

Free Obituaries & Memorials

In Loving Memory of Those We Have Loved & Those We Have Loved

The Unraveling

Just another weblog

Spokane Police Abuses: Past to Present

The People of Spokane vs. Law Enforcement Abuse, Impunity, Corruption, and Cover-up

Spiritual Man

The Journey to a Spiritual Life


A topnotch site

WatchBlog: Official Blog of the U.S. Government Accountability Office

GAO provides fact-based, nonpartisan information to Congress. The WatchBlog offers short, shareable insights from GAO reports on a wide variety of topics.


Welcome to the world of cats!

Tuck The Law Dog site

Snohomish County Reporter

Standing for those who cannot stand for themselves


Lake Stevens news source. Your community news source by choice. On Twitter @LSNewsSpot. Send news tips to:

Queen City +Addendum

Years ago, I thought up the name Queen. It's just a name. But it's regal, obviously, and -sounds splendid. ~ Freddie Mercury

Roger Goodman - Not A Good Man

The truth has finally come out... and it's not pretty.

Straight from the Horse's Heart

A Spiritual Ride through Love, Loss and Hope

Animal Law News & Abuse

Animal Rescuer & Owner resource site: news, views, civil rights, & politics

Dairy Carrie

Running the world while ignoring the dishes.

Don Charisma

because anything is possible with Charisma

The Dark Side of Animal Rescue

Stories about struggle, hope and love

Up on the Woof

Biscuits of dog-related stuff from author & animal advocate, C.A.Wulff

So Stupid ~ It's True

Stories from around the country that are so stupid that they have to be true

On the Mark

about our enemy the state

%d bloggers like this: